I have always been intrigued by the wing of the CRJ200. It lands weird. It's 'revolutionary'. It has a lore and history following it.
The best description of the aerodynamic characteristics of the airfoil on the CRJ200 and Challenger I have found is from the accident report on Challenger 604 90AG available here, pages 45-50, excerpted below:
The Challenger wing has supercritical aerofoil sections, ie sections designed to operate efficiently with substantial regions of supersonic flow while at the design cruise mach number (M). For high-speed subsonic aircraft in the transonic flight regime (M 0.7 to M 1.0) acceleration of the airflow over the wing causes the speed of the airflow over parts of the wing to exceed the speed of sound. A standing shock wave is formed towards the rear of the aerofoil where the airflow decelerates to subsonic speeds. A strong normal shock, with an associated high pressure gradient that can induce boundary layer separation (see 1.18.4.3), can result in a large increase in drag.
In comparison with previous types of aerofoil, supercritical aerofoils have a reduced camber, an increased leading edge radius, reduced curvature on the upper (suction) surface, and a concavity in the rear part of the lower (pressure) surface (Figure 5). At cruise conditions the profile maintains supersonic flow over a large part of the upper, suction surface of the aerofoil that is then decelerated towards the rear by a weak shock wave. As well as improving aerodynamic efficiency, the design allows a thicker wing section for a given aircraft critical mach number, providing for a more efficient wing structure and additional wing tank fuel capacity compared to previous types of high-speed aerofoil.
The first supercritical aerofoils were designed and analysed at the USA’s National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) Langley facility in the 1970s. Supercritical aerofoils have gained wide acceptance and are fitted to most modern high-speed commercial transport aircraft (eg Airbus, Boeing, Cessna Citation X, Raytheon Premier). The Challenger wing, designed by Bombardier (previously Canadair) in 1976, is believed to be the first production aircraft wing to utilise supercritical aerofoils; they are generally similar to those used on more recently designed wings. The Challenger aerofoil thickness/chord ratio (t/c) is relatively low, in common with virtually all current transonic aircraft, ranging from around 14% at the root to 10% at the tip.
While the CRJ200/Challenger is the first to have a supercritical airfoil, it's not unique compared to the aircraft that followed.
1.18.4.3 Wing Stall
The airflow in proximity to the wing surface is slowed by its passage over the surface to form a boundary layer (BL), ie a layer of air, generally adjacent to the surface, within which velocities are less than the free-stream velocity. Within the BL the local stream velocity increases with distance from the surface, with the outer edge of the BL defined as the location where the local velocity reaches 99% of free-stream velocity. In order to generate wing lift efficiently, the BL must remain relatively thin and generally attached to the surface. Separation of the BL from an extensive area of the upper surface of a wing results in a stall, causing substantial lift loss and drag increase. The lift coefficient CL, (a non- dimensionalised measure of lift) reaches a maximum (CLmax) at an AOA just below the stall angle.
Loss of energy from the BL can, if sufficient, cause flow separation. This can result from an excessive adverse pressure gradient, ie an excessive rate of increase in static pressure with distance from the point of peak suction (generally on the upper surface of the aerofoil leading edge). The BL over an aerofoil in an undisturbed airflow is initially laminar, ie streamwise flow within the BL without mixing across the BL. In practice, transition to turbulent flow (with mixing across the BL occurring) generally occurs after a short distance. Available evidence suggests that transition for the Challenger wing typically occurs at around 5% chord.
Supercritical aerofoils tend to generate a relatively flat suction profile over most of the wing upper surface at typical cruise angles of attack. At lower speeds, on both supercritical and conventional aerofoil sections with a relatively low t/c (in the order of 9-12%) the upper surface pressure profile develops an increasingly high and steep peak just behind the leading edge as the AOA increases. At high AOA the high adverse pressure gradient associated with a steep peak can cause the BL flow in the region to separate from the surface for part of its chordwise travel before transitioning to turbulent flow and reattaching to the wing upper surface, forming a laminar separation bubble.
The chordwise extent of the bubble increases with increasing AOA and the stall AOA at a particular spanwise wing station is reached when the flow does not reattach, ie the separation bubble bursts, producing a major reduction in the net suction over the upper profile of the section. Depending on the wing geometry, this change in flow pattern in one spanwise region can influence the flow at adjacent wing stations. This can cause the collapse to extend rapidly across the whole of one wing, causing a sudden major reduction in the lift and increase in the drag generated by that wing. The flow separation near the leading edge produces a more abrupt loss of lift than for the thicker aerofoil types (greater than 15% t/c) more typical of previous, lower-speed aerofoils, where the initial separation tends to occur nearer the trailing edge.
Flow separation is much more abrupt at the leading edge in a supercritical airfoil.
The upper surface suction peak becomes higher and steeper as the curvature of the flow around the leading edge becomes tighter. The upper surface curvature can be reduced at high AOA by use of an aerofoil with a drooped leading edge, rather than a generally symmetrical leading edge, as used on the Challenger wing. The manufacturer noted that appreciable droop would severely degrade the high speed performance of the wing and would therefore be impracticable. The suction peak is also increased by deflection of trailing edge flaps. A common means of suppressing the peak is the addition of leading edge slats or flaps, deploying in concert with trailing edge flaps.
The use of flaps eases some of the abrupt stall characteristics, but what makes the CRJ200/Challenger stall characteristics more abrupt than other supercritical airfoils is the absence of slats.
It is traditional practice on lower performance aircraft to arrange the wing geometry such that the wing root regions stall at a lower AOA than the tip regions in order to minimise the rolling moment due to lift asymmetry between the wings at incipient stall. However, this is usually impractical for a wing with the appreciable sweep that is normally used for modern transport aircraft in order to increase the transonic cruise speed. Such designs typically aim to force the initial stall to occur near mid span. The aircraft manufacturer reported that flight testing has shown that the wing stall for the Challenger typically begins at the leading edge of the outboard section of one of the wings. The manufacturer noted that flight testing had shown that, with N90AG’s take-off configuration and Mach Number, the uncontaminated Challenger wing would stall in free air (ie out of ground effect) at a sensor AOA of 25-26°, in the absence of appreciable sideslip. Ground effect would reduce the angle by an estimated 3-4° when the aircraft height above ground was 0-10 feet.
The manufacturer noted that the aircraft’s response is highly dependent on pilot actions once the stall is detected and that large variations in roll rate and peak roll angle can occur. Aileron inputs would normally be ineffective in controlling the roll rate once a wing had stalled, until it was unstalled by reducing the overall AOA. Data for sample Challenger flight test stalls with flaps at 20° showed appreciable wing drops, with roll rates up to 70°/second and bank angles up to 85°. Other information indicated that a rapid wing-drop at the stall would be likely to occur in most cases, irrespective of pilot technique. It was intended that the SPS would prevent the aircraft from reaching a wing stall condition.
None of that sounds very good.
1.18.4.4 Effect of Roughness
The available information showed that the lift characteristics of wings at a high AOA can be appreciably changed by a relatively small level of surface roughness. The earlier transition to turbulent flow promoted by roughness could be expected to delay BL separation. However, the evidence indicated that where the individual roughness elements are of a height that is substantial compared to the thickness of the BL they can, if sufficiently dense, significantly affect the character of the BL, making it prone to earlier separation. For wings with a low t/c, this can cause the separation bubble to burst (see 1.18.4.3) at an AOA appreciably below the uncontaminated stall AOA. The effects could reportedly be related to a ‘Roughness Parameter’ (Rp), defined as: Rp = 10A(k/c)N Where: A = Cross-sectional area of an individual roughness element (square inch) k = Roughness element height (inch) c = Aerofoil chord (inch) N = Roughness distribution density (number of elements per square inch). The Rp for a JAR and FAA definition of a ‘small amount of ice’ was reportedly 365-474 x 10-6.
Published information indicated that, on low t/c aerofoils, roughness on the leading edge alone would generally have a major effect and typically cause a reduction of CLmax in the order of half that which would result from distributed roughness (ie over the whole upper surface, including the leading edge). The information suggested that a relatively small degree of roughness could typically cause reductions in the order of 30% for CLmax and 5° for stall AOA compared to an uncontaminated wing. Preliminary independent calculations based on the published information and on N90AG’s FDR data were consistent with similar reductions in CLmax and stall AOA for N90AG just after lift-off.
Further estimates were made by the aircraft manufacturer. The effects of wing surface contamination on the Challenger stall could not be determined directly from flight test data or from simulation model predictions. The manufacturer used Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) techniques, validated by wind tunnel and flight tests, to estimate the effects. These indicated that contamination on the leading edge was particularly significant; combined contamination on the leading edge and the wing and flap upper surfaces causes only slight reductions in peak lift and stalling angle compared to contamination on the leading edge alone.
The fuselage AOA at which N90AG began to roll to the left after lift-off was estimated from the FDR data as 7.8°. This was 5.3° lower than the 13.1° fuselage AOA at which it was predicted that an uncontaminated wing would stall. The manufacturer’s CFD analysis estimated that, if the wing-drop had been caused by a premature stall of the left wing due to wing leading edge and upper surface contamination, the 5.3° reduction in stall angle would have required an Rp at the critical wing station of 200-400 x 10-6.
A second analysis estimated that, if contamination had caused N90AG’s left wing to stall prematurely, the associated reduction in CLMAX was 0.5. CFD analysis indicated that this would require an Rp of 140-450 x 10-6 on the wing leading edge. This was of a similar order to the above estimate based on stall angle reduction. It was noted that the analysis indicated that an overall contamination thickness of up to 0.12 inches had little effect on the lift characteristics; the effects were dominated by the roughness.
Example dimensions for sample rectangular section roughness elements that would produce the above values of Rp were: Roughness Element Height Width Number per Linear Inch Rp x 106 (inch) (inch) (/inch) 0.019 0.020 10 140 0.022 0.020 10 200 0.032 0.020 10 400 0.034 0.020 10 450 As a comparison, measurements suggested an estimated Rp of approximately 300 x 10-6 for medium-fine emery abrasive paper (P100 grade).
1993 - CRJ100 C-FCRJ
Flight testing induced stall/spin that was unrecoverable.
1997 - Air Canada Flight 646
Ground effect stall during balked landing.
2000 - Challenger 604 FTBZ
The flying pilot had a reputation of excessive rotations rates 2x to 3x the recommended 3° per second using stick forces as high as 40lbs.
2002 - Challenger 604 90AG
A light layer of frost on left wing stalled the wing on takeoff.
2024 - CRJ200 9N-AME
The flying pilot had a reputation of excessive rotation rates, plus the weight & balance and calculated v speeds were invalid.
2026 - Challenger 650 N10KJ
Stall on takeoff due to contaminated wing and excessive rotation rate. The final report will hopefully investigate if this pilot had also developed a reputation of excessive rotation rates, or it was induced by the contaminated wing.